Readin’ Report: Call Me Traitor

By Cassie Birk

Edited by Carly Zimmerman

An early look at Everina Maxwell's first fantasy novel, out December 1st!

BEFORE WE DIVE IN…

Genre: Romantic Fantasy and Historical Fantasy

Genre: Romantasy meets Dark Academia with a nod towards Military Fantasy

Age Group: While geared towards adult readers, YA readers looking for another queer found family to connect with will find characters to root for

Content warnings for the following described on page: Slavery, Violence

Spice Level: This is not a spice-driven romantasy book with explicit scenes. This is a Slow. Burn. The romance side of this story sticks with cozy fumblings and snuggles

Page Count: 352 pages

Series: Nope! This is a standalone

ABOUT THE BOOK

Call Me Traitor jumps between the perspectives of En and Tamol.

En is a living weapon called a war-tank. Considered a subhuman tool by the military with no memories other than her current mission and runes embedded in her skin compelling loyalty to the archmagi, she is assigned to a pair of mages on a covert military mission to retrieve exiled traitors from their banishment in the Far Peninsula.

When the dangers of the Peninsula put En’s life and mission in jeopardy, she is forced to team up with Tamol who is totally definitely just a common soldier from a previous failed operation and definitely nothing more than that, no matter how hot and funny she is. Tamol is an absolute disaster of a soldier, but brilliant at magic and treats En not like a weapon to be deployed, but a person with value.

Tamol’s perspective centers mostly on a flashback of her testimony in court and earlier years at the mage’s college. Under truth serum, we are only left to assume she cannot lie about how she joined a seemingly normal group of students that had a better vision for the future of their empire. A group of talented mages that still failed at their goal, were not allowed to graduate and instead face a sentence of exile. Yet they may have knowledge of magic the empire wants badly enough to bring them back for.

Once En puts the pieces together, will she still be the heartless weapon that won’t think twice about turning Tamol in? 

READER PROFILE

You might find this book a great fit for your TBR if:

  • Everina Maxwell is a favorite author! While in a different world and genre than their other books, Maxwell’s character work really shines with continued use of forced proximity to heighten the romantic tension between some traumatized characters. If you thought Jainan had it rough, just wait for En.

  • You have read too much MCU fan fic with a genderbent Bucky or loved the deconstruction from brainwashed soldier to human in Some Desperate Glory by Emily Tesh.

  • All your favorite found families are gay and probably in over their heads like Becky Chamber’s Wayfarer series, City of Strife by Claudie Arseneault, The Last Sun by K.D. Edwards, and If Found, Return to Hell by Em X. Liu.

  • You are filling your winter months full of Dark Academia like If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio, An Academy for Liars by Alexis Henderson, A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik, and Catherine House by Elisabeth Thomas.  

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Everina Maxwell is the author of two sci-fi romances; Winter’s Orbit and Ocean’s Echo. They live and work in England, where they collect books and kill houseplants (Macmillan). Connect with them on Instagram.

WHAT READERS THINK

“I truly wished I could’ve loved this book, but there were so many aspects that left me unsatisfied. The only part of this book I actually cared about was En and her story. This book was so so boring until almost halfway through. Even the romance between En and Tamol was just lukewarm to me, as I felt the foundation of their relationship was written very weirdly. They had no chemistry. I got no buzzy feelings from them, sadly, because the first half of the book put me off so much. I could not bring myself to care about any other character in this book. Maybe the worst part of it all was how utterly boring the academia setting was. Not only that but the magic system was a little confusing and only small bits of it were revealed until well after halfway. Unfortunately I do not think this was for me!”—maddy on Goodreads

“Listen, you might be thinking that the magically conscripted soldier story has been done before and you are not wrong. HOWEVER. Call Me Traitor is doing it all: the cool magic system, the dastardly politics, the human relationships; everything works and I want a thousand more pages in this world please and thank you!!”—Megan Bellinger on Fable

BOOK REPORTER’S REVIEW

As a reader of Everina Maxwell’s two sci-fi romances, Winter’s Orbit and Ocean's Echo, I want to encourage folks who are coming directly to Call Me Traitor to focus on the characters. They are an author who is great at creating interesting worlds with interesting cultures I want to know more about, but the world they set the story in is secondary to the characters developing relationships with each other and looking past their own flaws to uncover love for each other.

For the plot girlies in the room, this will drive you totally nuts.

En and Tamol do not care about the warring political factions in the capital’s court and the history and knowledge of the ancient mages that time has forgotten nearly as much as I do. There will be unsolved world questions, but if you go into the book with the focus towards En and Tamol and how they are navigating being themselves in their slice of this incredible space, it’s hard not to look away as these two adorkable sapphics bring together themes of ideology, identity, and when those things should be set aside for a trust in the worthiness and goodness of others.

Thank you to NetGalley and the TOR team for providing an advanced digital copy for this report!


Want to shop the books in this article? Check out our bookshop.org list (affiliate link)

Next
Next

Readin’ Report: Fallen Beauty